Politics Volt Europa (Luxembourg)
Appearance
- Internet regulation and empowerment of citizens in the digital sphere beyond the Digital Services Act (DSA)
- So far, internet platforms that offer and share pornographic or illegal content have been little regulated. As a result, the protection of minors is not guaranteed, illegal content can be gathered, and even private videos are shamelessly shared without major tracking, to the chagrin of the aggrieved without much hope for improvement. This must change as a matter of urgency. This has now happened more or less at the European level by means of the Digital Services Act (DSA).29 But by no means is everything provided for in it, which is why we demand the following:
- Regulating porn platforms
- Porn platforms must finally be obliged to take serious action against the abuse of nude images on their channels and additionally ensure the protection of minors. There are three key points in the provisions of the DSA:
- Every person who uploads content must provide information about their identity.
- Trained moderators are to keep an eye on all content and intervene in critical cases.
- Separate reporting channels for misuse material should make reporting and removal easier and faster.
- However, we also demand that there be a better system for monitoring the protection of minors. The current situation is catastrophic (clicking a button that supposedly confirms the person is over 18 is enough for most platforms). Here we would have to think about systems where adult content stays behind a better barrier. Self-deleting scans of the identity card or similar documents are conceivable. (Similar to how it already works today at cigarette machines). Other systems that preserve internet anonymity are also possible: For example, software tools can be used to give parents the option of controlling devices via a youth protection app, so that, if possible, all questionable content must first be activated or permitted by a parent or guardian (such apps already exist for video game consoles, but would also be conceivable in general for all internet-enabled devices such as tablets, laptops, smartphones, etc.). Especially people who are affected by so-called revenge porn, deepfakes and other forms of image-based violence must be given more opportunities to defend themselves against it. Women are particularly affected by this kind of image-based sexual abuse.
- However, those affected still have no right to complain to the platform if hateful content against them has not been removed. So, if a platform refuses to delete hate speech, revenge porn, a defamation or even a death threat, those affected do not have the right to file a complaint directly with the platform. They are also not given the option of out-of-court dispute resolution. This right is only granted to users who want to complain about content that may have been wrongly deleted by platforms. This is not only incomprehensible, but also unfair! This detail creates a two-tier system between users. Moreover, millions of people who are affected by hate comments and fake news are left in the lurch.
- We therefore demand that those affected be guaranteed unconditional protection and be given the opportunity to defend themselves against such injustice!
- Power to the Users: Affected persons must be able to turn to authorities to have orders issued
- The DSA includes demands for more rights for users in its regulations. This primarily concerns those people who are personally affected by illegal online content. It should become possible for those affected to turn to the authorities and actively obtain orders against online platforms in order to eliminate illegal content from the world. An example: If a user is attacked online with death threats or racist incitement and a platform ignores her report and request for deletion, this person should be able to turn to the authorities and request removal through this channel. However, the DSA does not provide for a contact point.
- We therefore call for a specific, European digital contact point where those affected can report and thus complain as simply and centrally as possible.
- Open the black box: There should be more transparency about risks & impacts
- Online platforms currently shield all information around content moderation and the algorithms on which their systems are based. The platform HateAid, together with PeopleVsBigTech, an international coalition of civil society organisations, has argued that it is not justified to make this a trade secret.30 After all, since the handling of content of all kinds can have a significant impact on the well-being of users worldwide, it is important to gain insight into the mechanisms of platforms and, if necessary, to regulate them. This is all the more explosive in light of Frances Haugen's revelations with the Facebook files. As a former Meta employee, she revealed that the company uses certain algorithms to preferentially disseminate hateful content in order to make profits. For the European Parliament, transparency is therefore the key word.The risks to public safety, health, fundamental rights and a number of other areas must be critically assessed by very large online platforms. Much might have been prevented if such measures had been introduced earlier. For example, there might be countless fewer teenagers suffering from mental health problems due to the negative effects of Instagram.
- We therefore demand that information on how the content moderation of a platform works be made visible in a legally regulated manner.
- Access to platform data also for NGOs
- It was not only AlgorithmWatch, which had to shut down its Instagram monitoring project to avoid risking a Facebook lawsuit, that suffered from big tech's caginess in the past. Other organisations also shied away from accessing their data for fear of possible charges by big platforms.31 The DSA is now raising hopes that this could soon change. The European Parliament's regulations stipulate that not only researchers, but also certain civil society
organisations should have access to platform data.
- We support this.
Back to Politics